NYC Subway CX Kills Chivalry in the City
Brands with values inspire customers who interact with them. Nike encourages us to be brave and embrace our differences. The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation urges us to be kind and care for others. Brands like this use the CX Pyramid to promote their values and deliver the reliable experiences customers want.
When Brands Hurt Customers
On the flip side, brands also have the power to make customers feel ignored, and even angry. The CX Pyramid crumbles and customer-to-customer behavior, in addition to individual experiences, suffer. Case in point, the New York MTA System and the MTA experience.
In the past year, New York City MTA riders have felt used, at best. It’s a trend that has characterized the last decade of the MTA’s brand story, and it has come to a head in recent months. The MTA Customers Count Survey tries to fix that perception. Unfortunately a VOC program (customer feedback) is only the beginning of the solution to problems that continue to grow.
Riders today pay almost two times more for the same ride they took 20 years ago. The perception, based on rider experience, is that they are getting worse service and less value for more money. In this environment, where does customer experience management come into play?
Experience Management and Expectation Management
Customer experience management is as much expectation management as it is experience management. With that in mind, take a look at how the MTA delivers (or doesn’t deliver) on customer experience management.
For riders, it feels like lack of access to reliable transportation, at a high cost, is becoming the norm. F Train stations in Queens and Brooklyn skip the same stations on weekends for more than ten years because of “renovations.” People who live in neighborhoods where the F Train is the only choice, feel under-served. This summer, half of Astoria (a trendy Queens neighborhood) was shut down for renovations. Local stops along Manhattan’s Central Park West, still under construction, were closed for the summer. Service interruptions and service suspensions are common all across the subway system.
MTA Experience: When the CX Pyramid Breaks Down
The CX Pyramid represents the layers of delivery a brand aspires to fulfill. Those three layers include meeting needs, providing an easy experience, and making the experience enjoyable. MTA service suspensions do not meet the needs of a significant segment of riders. Crowded, unreliable trains during peak hours do not make it easy to get to work on time.
The MTA made some attempts to meet customer needs by installing rider information signs that display when the next train is arriving and how long customers need to wait. Unfortunately, when riders wait for crowded trains in the morning, their anxiety about missing the train and the length of the wait time, eliminates the perceived benefits of those expensive new signs.
Bad Customer Experience has a Ripple Effect
How does this bad customer experience influence the behavior of New York subway riders? Riders feel like they are not appreciated, like their time and needs are not respected by a brand they have no choice but to interact with on a daily basis. It’s human nature for those feelings to affect behaviors. This summer and fall, I have experienced the breakdown of common decency among riders firsthand.
The MTA has created a culture in which the experience of the rider no longer matters.
Riding the MTA has been the most disappointing experience of my pregnancy. A true New Yorker, I have been on the subway for more than 15 years. The lack of regard for me and the lack of civility towards me and my baby broke my heart. And it surprised me. It didn’t used to be like this. Riders across the system from all age groups and cultural backgrounds refused to make space for us.
Better Experiences Start at the Brand Level
So whose fault is it that chivalry is dead across New York’s public transportation system? If we take a moment to observe how the MTA treats riders, we quickly see the brand and its level of service set the tone. Thanks to unreliable service and unpredictable (though frequent) service disruptions, the customer journey during rush hour is anxiety-ridden and frustrating. If it rains or snows, all bets are off. Commuting is a nightmare.
Last, but definitely not least, if there is any misconduct on the train (like a woman shoving me while I was 7 months pregnant and carrying a suitcase) there is no one around to hear a complaint, or to help. The MTA does not stand for customer service in general. This is compounded when things go wrong and riders can’t get help.
Better Customer Experience Improves Customer-to-Customer Behavior
How can we bring civility back and improve consideration and politeness among riders? Is it/should it be the MTA’s responsibility to make civility a priority?
Since the MTA is a brand that serves the public, caring for each other should be part of the brand’s underlying values and mission. Safety, caring and service need to drive a campaign to rebrand the MTA.
The Customers Count Survey is a start, but it feels operational.
When the operation is as complex and entrenched as the MTA, it is impossible to promise consistent punctual service and to deliver on that promise. A smart, strong brand can improve service, while developing a brand identity with civil characteristics that inspires riders to be there for each other and be kind to those in need.
Instead of a massive communications campaign to extol the MTA’s crowning achievement of opening the 2nd Avenue Line after decades of construction delays and red tape, the MTA should use ad space on trains to remind riders of the meaning of the word CARE. At the brand level, they need to educate riders about the small, but deep expressions of caring they can show each other. Reminders to get up for a pregnant woman, to make space for others by taking off a backpack, or to use headphones, can improve the culture of the MTA and improve rider experience in real ways.
The MTA carries 1.7 billion people per year. With such a place in the world, it is time for the brand to take a social stand to protect those in need. As a seasoned New Yorker, I should not be afraid to ride the train because of my pregnancy. Unfortunately, this is how I feel today. I am not alone in feeling abandoned, ignored, underappreciated and overcharged.
Create Customer-Centric Cultures
Become a Member of The Petrova Experience.
4 Career Tips to obtain a Customer Experience Role
In honor of the 4th of July, we are rounding up 4 career tips for CX professionals. Set aside some time during the break from work to take stock in your CX career and evaluate the steps you need to get to the next level.
Brand and Customer Experience – Make the Customer Know Who You Are
Now that we have helped you become experts in the design of space and function and the design of feelings, it is time to turn our attention to aesthetics, and to connect customer experience…
3 Ways to Create a Better Employee Experience Strategy
Guest Post by Gabe Smith, CCXP for The Petrova Experience The relationship between employee experience strategy and customer experience has long been discussed. Without engaged employees, we’re told, it’s difficult…
Customer Experience Audit: New York Times Beats Google
Editor’s Note: This post is part of a series of Customer Experience Audits. In this series we walk you through customer experience examples across industries. We feature brands that made…
Customer Experience Audit: Domino’s Making the Right CX Choices
Editor’s Note: This post is part of a series of Customer Experience Audit – as series of articles featuring examples of good customer experience and bad customer experience in practice….
Employee Engagement and Wellness In The Workplace: Guest Post
Today, The Petrova Experience brings you a guest article about employee engagement, by Natlie DeVito of Commonwealth Joe. Commonwealth Joe is an innovative company, new to the New York City…
Customer Experience Design – How Do You Want Customers To Feel?
Last week, we talked about CX Design in terms of space and function. Today, we continue our customer experience design journey to talk about the design of emotions and feelings. All…
Customer Facing Experience: Communication and Hospitality
Today, we are talking about communication as part of the customer facing experience. This is one of the most misused and misinterpreted notions both in our professional lives and our…
Do You Know Why The Iconic Brand Toys ‘R’ Us Closed Doors Despite All Our Memories? #RetailBlues
The year is 2016. You are the CEO of Toys ‘R’ Us. Your brand still controls 13.6% of the toy market although the company is highly leveraged, a strategy of…
Hospitality Experience and Why We lack Seamless Travel Experiences
Hospitality is taken for granted across government agencies, airlines and hotels. In my line of work, I often hear “I want to have the JetBlue customer experience.” Although many claim…
Customer Experience Audit: FedEx Omnichannel Disaster
In our Strategy, Org Design & Culture series, we cover customer-focused companies that are willing to adapt, take risks and discover new ways of staying relevant. Sometimes, we encounter brands…
Customer Experience Survey: Why Customers Are Not Responding
When you solicit customer feedback sometimes matters more than how you ask the questions. In the case of a survey about new biometrics boarding initiatives my team and I created for JetBlue, we had a list of feedback that was most important for us.
WeWork Does CX Right with a Wow Moment
Used at the right time and place along the customer’s journey, the Wow Moment is an excellent retention technique. When a brand creates personal, relevant experience at exactly the right time, it can build a lifelong, loyal customer relationship.
Poor Integration is Bad for Customer Journey and Worse for Brands
Although we all have bad customer experiences, there is still a big debate about “the CX field” and whether it will survive the test of time. There is no doubt…
How To Define Your Purpose And Have Unique Culture
If you Google the word “purpose” you get the definition “the reason for which something exists.” This is a challenge if you think about it in the context of an…
Why you need a defined culture for customer experience?
When designed and built correctly, customer experience expresses an organization’s brand. Your brand and marketing promises serve as a guiding light to your experience team. Similarly, organizational culture serves as a goalpost for the service side of customer experience.
How to talk to your CFO about customer experience and revenue growth
Last month we introduced the topic of Customer Experience ROI and the complexity of building a good business case for it. The Customer Experience business case is strong, but not easy to prove. Today we will focus on two big wins of a successful customer experience investment – revenue and customer growth of your business.
The One CX Goal You Need to Set for 2019
For 2019, I urge you to make only one CX goal – bring about business success with your customer experience work. Don’t just do work in the general sense. Rather, set a CX goal that has a real impact on your customers and their experiences with your brand.
Aviation Industry, Coronavirus Isn’t the Only Thing Killing Us
Eighteen years ago, September 11th caused a three-day halt of the US commercial airlines and resulted in a 31.6% reduction in travel in September 2001 compared to the previous year….
Customer Experience Technology View of your Call Center
By 2022 the global cloud based contact center market is growing from USD 6.8Bn in 2017 to 20.93Bn in 2022. This makes for CAGR of 25.2%. If you do not…
Leadership During the Pandemic: Guest Post by Rachel Dreyfus
This is a guest post by Rachel Dreyfus, President, Dreyfus Advisors, who researched leadership during the pandemic. How has Covid19 influenced leadership over the past three months? Research results show…
Hiring Tips: Who Should I Hire First on My CX Team
The pressure to demonstrate business impact and ROI on your Customer Experience initiatives quickly makes your first hire even more important. As usual, there is no answer that fits all scenarios perfectly. We have some helpful strategies to consider based on the structure of your organization and your goals.
Is Covid19 What We Needed to Build Seamless End-to-End Travel Experience?
On January 10th, we published an article called The Future of Travel We Deserve. In it, we laid out the foundation necessary to implement innovation at scale. Four months later,…
United CEO does not care about #customers happiness. Really?
Lately, I have been thinking about United Airlines. In the beginning I thought about them because someone asked whether it is possible to build a customer-centric culture in a company…
A Customer Experience Strategy will Define Your Success in 2021
While there may not be a magic pill to guarantee the perfect customer experience, there is one thing that every organization needs to transform into a customer-centric business. And that…
Paperless Customer Journey – JetBlue Deviceless Boarding
JetBlue Biometrics – Innovation and Disruption This year, JetBlue entered the ranks of the innovators who disrupt industries by applying customer experience technology. They not only imagine the future. They…
Get Customer Experience Basics Right and You Don’t Need to Invest in Wow Moments
Wow Moments are a Customer Experience hot topic. Customer experience professionals ideate how to build, prioritize, finance, and measure these Wow Moments. Chip and Dan Heath wrote a whole book on the topic: The Power of Moments. No Wow Moment saves you from negative word of mouth if your brand fails to get the customer experience basics right or to deliver the expected brand experience consistently.
What is Customer Experience? What are the Faces of CX?
Each area of CX represents a path for CX professionals to impact business health and build successful careers. One of my favorite CX analogies is that it is like the blood in our bodies. When CX is done well, it touches every aspect of an organization. That’s what makes customer experience so much fun! You will never be bored working in CX.
Airport Experience – Are You Letting Down Your Precious 2021 Travelers?
A month and a half ago, as part of our ongoing conversation about airport experience, we introduced the concept of revenge travel. We pleaded with the public to trust us…
Organizational Culture and Access to Information
By and large, people perceive culture as an HR discipline. The most common perception is that culture covers the soft side of performance. Culture is about how you do things, not so much about what you do. This approach to culture could not be more wrong. In fact, organizational culture is about so much more than a few words in a performance review sheet. It is about leaders expressing values, and the action guidance their cultural behaviors provide.
Customer Experience Audit: eBay’s Vibrant Marketplace of the Future
Editor’s Note: This post is part of a series of Customer Experience Audits. They highlight advances in artificial intelligence in retail and other technologies. See all audit stories. Two years…
Customer Experience Tips and Best Practices In 2017?
This is Post 2 of Liliana Petrova’s series on customer experience tips, lessons learned, and best practices for the new year. The article appears on the JetBlue Blog. In it,…
What Can Casino Consulting Firms Learn from Airlines?
Today we’re talking about casino experience. Casinos and airlines are similar in their operational complexity and sense of wonder. They also are similar in the way they can implement technology…
How a Personal Interaction builds Repeat Customers
A customer-centric methodology is key to the successful outcome of my interaction with Hello Spud. It is the reason this story appears here, and not among the CX Big Fails! The company did not send an automated response. It did not deliver a message stating “sorry we couldn’t help you, would you like something else.” Instead, the company co-founder reached out to me personally across multiple channels (a handwritten note, followed by personal emails).
Would You Pitch In To Save Toys “R” Us For Your Children To Experience? #ToysRUsGoFundMe
Last week we laid out the big moves that the leadership of Toys ‘R’ Us failed to take to evolve with customer needs and thus joins other brands as examples of…
Patient Experience Trends in 2021 – Telehealth is Here to Stay
Today, we continue our series about 2021 Customer Experience trends and tactics. We take a closer look at patient experience and what telehealth means for the future. Both for patients…
Customer Experience Audit: Mobile Provider Eliminates Remote Workforce
How to balance the efficiency call center metric FCR (first call resolution) with wait and talk time? JetBlue promotes human interactions as a brand promise.
Customer Experience Audit: Uber Bets On Self-Driving Cars With Big Volvo Purchase
The question that remains unanswered is who will be part of the future of transportation. Uber is going for the vertical integration – the whole pie. The future industry of urban transportation will be made of players in three different categories: cars, self-driving software, and ride-sharing network. In contrast, Lyft approaches the future through partnerships.
What is Human-Centered Design and how to Leverage it in 2021?
At its core, design is about value creation. In the world of Customer Experience, value-driven design requires CX professionals to use empathy to imagine a future customer experience that is…
Culture Starts at the Top
Without a leader who believes that today’s business success is about acquiring and retaining customers, you cannot even begin the process of building a culture. Leaders who are passionate about the customer are also passionate about creating culture and employee engagement.
Customer Experience Audit: Cadillac Scores Millennial Customers with Future-Forward Thinking
Editor’s Note: This post is part of a Customer Experience Audit series. See all the audit stories. The automotive industry is right next to the airline industry in terms of…
Customer Experience Plan is More Important than Ever
Last week we published eight Customer Experience Trends to look out for in 2021. Today we are diving deeper into the first one: Customer Experience is more important than ever…
Liliana Petrova Talks Patient Experience in Healthcare Podcast
Recently, we recorded a podcast on patient experience in healthcare with Stacey Richter. Today, we are excited to share it with you. On the episode, we discuss travel and healthcare…
Are You Ready to Go Exclusive with Jane, Your Digital Concierge?
In 2015 JetBlue introduced bag fees. Seven years after the competition. The media exploded. Many publications were negative. They blamed the airline for “selling out.” One headline read “A New…
Healthcare Whitepaper: Impact of Patient ‘I Wants’ in Healthcare
Rachel Dreyfus joins The Petrova Experience with a guest blog about patient experience. Background A culture of positive patient experience is increasingly important in Healthcare, affecting patient outcomes and satisfaction….
Lessons Learned at the Forrester Conference: “Data is the New Sexy”
Once a year I look for an event to attend where I can learn something new and get better at what I do. This year, I attended an event hosted…